By Rabbi Yair Hoffman for

It was a very bizarre scene involving an anonymous hero, a drunken cop, a guy at minyan and the video that captured it all.

Apparently, a man was driving with his girlfriend and noticed a very erratic driver.  The driver was obviously drunk and the anonymous man decided to pursue the drunken driver and film it – with his girlfriend along for the ride.  The incident occurred in the heart of Jewish Flatbush – at the corner of Ocean Parkway and Avenue P.

The drunken driver, Tanvir Ahmed, 28, who turned out to be a cop, continued driving down Ocean Parkway and smashed into a car parked across from the Bnai Yoseph Shul.  The religious Jewish owner of the vehicle came out of shul and opened the door of the drunken driver – only to be punched in the right side of his face by the drunken police officer.

The drunken driver continued down the service road of Ocean Parkway, but right before Quentin, the anonymous hero and his girlfriend angled the car so that the drunken driver could not proceed further.  The anonymous hero approached the drunk driver, opened his door and demanded that he come out of the car.

When Ahmed stopped at the Quentin Road intersection, the unidentified motorist pulled in front of the Altima and blocking its path before getting out of his car. The motorist approached Ahmed, opening the driver’s side door and ordering him out of his vehicle.  The anonymous hero noticed that the drunk driver was a police officer from the 67th precinct and continued to expressed his shock in unyeshivesh language while waiting for other, more sober officers to arrive.

Police eventually charged officer Ahmed with assault, driving while intoxicated, leaving the scene of an accident ,and refusing to take a breathalyzer test.


So, what is the halacha in all of this?  Should the anonymous hero have pursued the drunken driver?  What Mitzvah or Mitzvos was he performing – if any?   Should he have taken along his girlfriend? Should the guy coming out of shul have opened the drunk’s car door?  Is the drunken police officer exempt from responsibility for punching the shul attender because he was drunk?


Let’s start with the anonymous hero.  He was fulfilling a Mitzvah in pursuing the drunk driver – because a drunk driver endangers human life.  Saving life is a fundamental Mitzvah. What is the source of this Mitzvah? The verse in Parshas Ki Taytzai (Dvarim 22:2) discusses the Mitzvah of Hashavas Aveida – returning an object with the words, “Vahashaivoso lo – and you shall return it to him.” The Gemorah in Sanhedrin (73a), however, includes within its understanding of these words the obligation of returning “his own life to him as well.” For example, if thieves are threatening to pounce upon him, there is an obligation of “Vahashaivoso lo.” In other words, this verse is the source for the Mitzvah of saving someone’s life. This, in all probability, is general Mitzvah that the Shulchan Aruch refers to in Shulchan Aruch Orech Chaim 325.


There is a negative Mitzvah of not standing idly by your brother’s blood as well. This is mentioned in Shulchan Aruch (CM 426:1) and in the Rambam.


There is yet another negative commandment associated with the positive commandment of Hashavas Aveida, and that is the verse in Dvarim (22:3), “You cannot shut your eyes to it.” This verse comes directly after the Mitzvah of Hashavas Aveidah. The Netziv (HeEmek Sheailah) refers to this Mitzvah as well.


The Sheiltos (Sheilta #37), based upon the Gemorah in Bava Metziah 62a, understands these words to indicate an obligation to save others with you. The Netziv in his He’Emek She’ailah understands it as a full-fledged obligation according to all opinions. He writes that he must exert every effort to save his friend’s life – until it becomes Pikuach Nefesh for himself.


The Ramban, Toras haAdam Shaar HaSakana (p42-43) understands the verse of “And love thy neighbor as yourself” as a directive to save him from danger as well. Although he discusses the issue of medical danger, it is clear that this is an example, and it would apply to danger from physical enemies as well. Even without the Ramban, however, it is clear that defending and protecting someone from danger is a fulfillment of this Mitzvah.


This is a difficult question.  While the anonymous hero was justified in risking his life to save others – he was risking his life in case the drunk had a knife or a gun – something that is not uncommon.  Did he have a right to bring his girlfriend along in the pursuit and subject her to such a danger?  For the time being, we can assume that since she did not voice an objection and the chance of danger to her was somewhat remote – it was permitted.


A drunk driver is a rodaif because he endangers human life (See Teshuvos V’hanhagos Vol. I #850 from Rav moshe Shternbuch Shlita).

The Vilna Gaon on Choshain Mishpat 388:12 rules that even if the person is unaware that he is endangering people – he is still considered a Rodaif.  It should be noted that a rodaif must first be stopped in other ways before applying deadly force. There is also a fascinating Ohr Sameach that states that one can even employ deadly force to a rodaif even in a situation where what the rodaif has done is exempt from financial liability (See his words on Rambam Hilchos Rotzaiyach 1:8).

Being drunk is no excuse for anything – neither the car damage nor the assault on the minyan attender – Adam mu’ad l’olam – a person is always responsible for his actions.


He too was involved in the performance of the Mitzvah in attempting to stop the drunken driver.  Unfortunately, he was not successful – apparently not having anticipated the punch and the escape.  In terms of schar, merit – it does not matter.  The great Rosh Yeshiva Rav Avrohom Pam zatzal once remarked that we can appreciate the reward one gets from trying to save life from the punishment that is meted out to a maisis umadiach.  He incurs the death penalty for an action that didn’t happen and the very person that the Maisis tried to lure was the person who turned him in.  If this is true for an aveirah – how much more is the reward for trying to save life!

The author can be reached at


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here